Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Resolution 243-9 is about Reparative Justice. What Could a Better Resolution Look Like?

Currently under consideration by the upcoming diocesan convention of the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey (November 20-21, 2026) is Resolution 243-9,[1] put forward by the recently constituted diocesan Reparative Justice Financial Board. The Board is proposing their 2026 resolution in response to 2025 convention Resolution 242-5,[2] in part to clarify the amount and source of funds that will populate the reparative justice trust created by the 2025 resolution. As Resolution 243-9 is currently under consideration, now is the time to reflect on whether it is as good as it could be, and, if not, what would make for a better Resolution.

 

First I want to thank the members of the Reparative Justice Financial Board for their work to try to produce the 2026 resolution. I'm sure this process has not been easy, but unfortunately, as it stands, the resolution does not adequately address the deep need for reparative justice for the Historically Black Congregations (HBCs) of the Diocese of New Jersey which the 2025 resolution called for. What follows is an articulation both of serious concerns with the content of Resolution 243-9, and of ideas for more adequate alternatives which hopefully can be incorporated in the future.

 

Though much of the non-financial language is largely unobjectionable (of course a wider campaign to solicit additional funds for the trust is necessary; of course the rest of the diocese needs to contribute; of course more education is necessary; of course additional governance changes are necessary), the resolution statements on these matters are vague. What are the details? If the comparatively more detailed treatment in the resolution of the binding financial commitments upon the diocese are any guide for how the vague statements will later be fulfilled, we should feel very great concern. That is because the financial proposals articulated in the resolution do not go nearly far enough in addressing the known harms they is meant to address. 

 

We will consider first the third financial element described: a suspension of “Marks of Mission” giving requirements for HBCs for three years.[3] The “Marks of Mission” giving is essentially the diocesan tithe levied on individual congregations. No doubt, the Marks of Mission giving requirements on HBCs should be suspended, but the proposal is only for a temporary three-year suspension. Of course, it should be up to HBCs whether to act on this suspension and to choose whether to accept it. But there is no reason to make such a suspension temporary unless the goal is for it to default back to a requirement again. There is no need for the temporary language. A further resolution could always restore the requirement if somehow racism ends, or the wealth gap is closed, or history erased. But leaving the suspension temporary in the Resolution suggests that the suspension itself is not truly a necessary reparative act, and is only a measure enacted as long as the diocesan leaders involved believe there is available money and political will.[4] Is it being viewed, perhaps, just a magnanimous gift[5] from a majority white institution that is neither necessary nor permanently binding? None of these understandings or rationales is accurate or appropriate. For this reason, a more appropriate resolution would make the suspension of the Marks of Mission obligation permanent, not temporary.

 

A much larger issue however pertains to the positive financial commitments made in the resolution, specifically the $1 million diocesan commitment over three years to the Trust (the second financial element mentioned in the Resolution), and the 3% commitment to the Trust from diocesan real estate sales (the first financial measure mentioned). Unfortunately these provisions are essentially white supremacist in nature, a fact which can be seen when considered in light of the larger context in which they appear.

 

Part of this financial background can be seen through the assertion in the “Statement in Support of Resolution 243-9 by Proposers” that the diocese has aided HBCs over the past decade at the amount of approximately $4 million. If that figure is correct (and no supporting documentation for those numbers has yet been furnished) that works out to approximately $400,000 per year. If that has been the recent level of financial transfer from the diocese to the HBCs, that is certainly better than nothing, but there is no indication in the resolution that this level of support is guaranteed to continue. Certainly the resolution itself does not bind the diocese to that level of funding going forward. If the board expects this level of support to continue, it should be made formally binding in writing.[6] The only reasons not to enshrine this level of reparative financial commitment formally in a binding resolution are either negligence, or to free the diocese to renege on such a verbal or tacit commitment. Neither reason is acceptable.

 

Moreover, as regards the formally proposed $1 million commitment: standard endowment management practices would lock away the overwhelming majority of that money in order to draw no more than 4-5% per year to preserve the principal. So even by the end of the proposed 3-year period it is unlikely that the yearly commitment to the HBCs implied by the resolution’s $1 million commitment to the Trust would be greater than one tenth of what the diocese has already been doing (i.e. the draw for reparative justice for HBCs would only be at most about $50,000/year). If this is meant to be a replacement for what the diocese has been doing it is a failure. If it is intended as a supplement to the yearly ~$400,000 it is still not nearly enough to make any kind of systemic difference and is certainly nothing to congratulate ourselves about. Were we really already doing 90% of what reparative justice was required? I think not.[7]

 

Further, there is the 3% commitment to the Trust of proceeds from diocese-sold real-estate property transactions. Diocesan leadership had last year regularly proposed a level of commitment at the 6-7% level. However, even a 6-7% commitment is not actually reparative, as worshipping Episcopalians at HBCs constitute well over 6-7% of the worshipping population of the diocese. The commitment would need to be dramatically higher to constitute a redistribution of funds.[8] And that would only constitute an attempt to be equitable going forward and do nothing to compensate for past wrongs. Doing even less than half the previously suggested inadequate commitment is a gross wrong. Not to mention the fact that if no qualifying real estate is sold, there is no commitment here whatsoever. A more adequate resolution would commit all proceeds from diocesan real-estate sales to the Trust for the foreseeable future, and would include a plan for which properties will be sold.[9]

 

The fact is that this resolution formally guarantees a commitment of what will amount to less than two-hundred-thousand dollars per year total to the HBCs (the majority of which is just a temporary promise not to take more funds), and does not guarantee the previous level of funding (which was more than twice as great).

 

A more just resolution would commit ALL proceeds from diocesan real-estate transactions to the fund, and would need to commit to a fund size of at least $10 million in order to ensure merely that the current, and widely recognized as inadequate level of positive support for HBCs is maintained (dramatically more than that if it were to be considered a significant new commitment to additional reparative justice). 

 

I understand that those who support the resolution will say that it recognizes the need to do more, but the document as it stands threatens, not merely to establish a precedent for doing far less than is required to meet the needs of justice, but to establish a precedent for doing even far less than the diocese was already doing.

 

My goal in writing is to support the work of reparative justice and to support the efforts of the Board to improve upon their work in the future. I thank you for your work thus far. All I can say is that I agree with the text of the resolution that asserts that much more is necessary as we move forward to ensure that justice is actually done. Please consider this an open invitation to conversation and an offer to help improve the work in the future. I firmly believe that full transparency and real collaboration will produce better results.

 

Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski, Ph.D.

Reparations Commission Research Historian

Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey




[1] The proposed 2026 resolution, put forward by the Reparative Justice Financial Board (a different entity from the Reparations Commission), can be found here: https://dioceseofnj.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Doc-09-Resolutions-Final.pdf. And here: https://dionj-racialjusticereview.blogspot.com/2026/11/resolution-243-9-regarding-diocesan.html.

[2] The text of the 2025 resolution, which was proposed by the Reparations Commission, and was passed with over 95% convention support, can be found here: https://dionj-racialjusticereview.blogspot.com/2025/11/news-diocesan- convention-approves.html. However, the original text of the resolution has been removed from the diocesan website. 

[3] The “Statement in Support of Resolution 243-9 by Proposers” suggests that this amounts to $420,000 over three years. That means it is approximately $140,00 per year (or at most 35% of what was already being done).

[4] Reparative financial commitments are not handouts. The return of stolen funds doesn’t make the people returning the funds good. They are simply doing what is required of them. Receiving back the funds that have been stolen from you does not make you dependent, or weak. It is simply what is owed to you. Reparative justice payouts are not white saviorism. They are owed. They are an obligation.

[5] It is not a gift. It is a negative measure that only stops requiring additional funds from HBCs. Moreover, it does nothing about the 100-year-plus history of having required it.

[6] Not promised in words, or based on a tacit understanding from a meeting that was never documented. If it is not made legally binding it is not adequate.

[7] Even if this number is combined with the yearly “Marks of Mission” suspension number it still adds up to less than $200,000 per year, which is less than 50% of what the diocese was already doing.

[8] Especially in light of the ongoing 20-1 racial wealth gap in New Jersey and the demonstrated history of underfunding of HBCs over the past century (https://dionj-racialjusticereview.blogspot.com/2026/06/the-cost-of-century-racism-to.html).

[9] Certainly at least until the Trust is populated to the point that it can permanently fund disbursements well over the past yearly commitments (which apparently were ~$400,000). To maintain the status quo from the Trust would require a Trust populated with $10 million. But acknowledging that what has been done is inadequate suggests that a more adequate degree of funding would be at least double that figure (i.e. a Trust of $20 million, producing a usable draw per year of $1 million for HBCs).

Sunday, November 15, 2026

Resolution 243-9 regarding "A Diocesan Commitment to Reparative Justice" proposed by the Reparative Justice Financial Board

Trinity Episcopal Cathedral, Trenton, NJ (location of the 243rd diocesan convention)
Farragutful, Trinity Episcopal Cathedral - Trenton 01, detail by Jolyon Pruszinski, CC BY-SA 4.0

The Diocese of New Jersey “Reparative Justice Financial Board”[1] has submitted a resolution to the Diocese of New Jersey Committee on Resolutions in advance of the 243rd Diocesan Convention (November 20-21, 2026). It is slated to be included in the consent calendar (the resolutions that will be voted on as a block, not individually). The text of “Resolution 243-9,” so-called “A Diocesan Commitment to Reparative Justice,” and the accompanying “Statement in Support of Resolution 243-9 by Proposers” is presented below and is drawn from pages 21-23 of the “Final Report of the Committee on Resolutions,” published by the Diocese of New Jersey.[2]

 

Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski, Ph.D.

Reparations Commission Research Historian

Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey

 

---

 

RESOLUTION 243-9: 

Subject: A Diocesan Commitment to Reparative Justice 

 

Be it resolved, That the 243rd Convention of the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey commit to the work of reparative justice by funding the Reparative Justice Trust Fund authorized and established by Resolution 242-5 of the 2025 Annual Diocesan Convention, as follows: 

 

• $1,000,000 to be funded over 3 years from diocesan funds that can legally be made available for this work, the specific funding sources and arrangements to be established by The Trustees of Church Property of the Diocese of New Jersey working in consultation with the Chief Financial Officer, the Treasurer, and others, and with the support of Diocesan Council, and 

 

• In addition to the $1,000,000 above, a commitment of at least 3% of the net sale proceeds of diocesan-held real estate sales over at least 3 years beginning January 1, 2027 and ending December 31, 2029, not including the sale of properties held in trust for active congregations or active developments still held by the Diocese of New Jersey in partnership with others, and 

 

• A waiver of Marks of Mission Giving Asking payments from Historically Black Churches for an initial period of 3 years beginning January 1, 2027 and ending December 31, 2029, subject to extension; any congregation wishing to pay the Marks of Mission Asking is welcome to do so. In order to offset the impact on the diocesan operating budget, the equivalent of these waived payments will be paid by an annual grant from the Mission Renewal Fund to the Operating Budget and will not be due from the congregations, and 

 

• A fundraising campaign to encourage individuals, institutions, and groups to contribute to the Reparative Justice Trust Fund, to be administered by the Reparative Justice Financial Board; and be it 

 

Further resolved, That the Diocese commit itself to education and conversation about the sin of racism, the harm done to people of African descent, and the need for reparative justice, giving thanks for the faithful work of the Anti-Racism Commission and the Reparations Commission in calling members and congregations to learn, acknowledge, and repent, while recognizing that there is still much work to do, committing together to efforts to engage all congregations in ongoing learning, growth, and action; and be it 

 

Further resolved, That the Reparative Justice Financial Board bring forward to the 244th Convention a further financial proposal for congregational assessments toward the Reparative Justice Trust Fund, together with a proposal for ongoing governance of the Fund, to ensure that oversight is offered by a governing body led by, and with majority membership from, people of African descent; and be it 

 

Further resolved, That this Convention affirm that the work of Reparative Justice is long and extensive, and therefore direct the Reparative Justice Financial Board to continue to make recommendations to the Convention on additional steps to extend and grow the Reparative Justice Trust Fund to support the ministries of the Historically Black Churches of the Diocese. 

 

Submitted by: The Reparative Justice Financial Board. 

 

Statement in Support of Resolution 243-9 by Proposers: 

 

This proposal provides $1,000,000 in Reparative Justice Trust Fund contributions and an estimated $420,000 in additional congregational support over three years, plus contributions from eligible real-estate sale proceeds and fundraising. 

 

We recognize that ongoing racism continues to harm all members of our diocese while placing a particular burden on People of Color, and it is our shared responsibility as members of the Diocese of New Jersey to seek justice and work to respond faithfully to the harm done to our siblings in Christ through the sin of racism. This funding of the Reparative Justice Trust Fund is a step forward in financial support, even as we are called to do this work in other areas as well. We commit together to the ongoing conversation and mutual support that bring about the beloved community. 

 

The Diocese of New Jersey has a long history of funding congregational support in ways that have not always been equitable. In recent years, we have renewed our commitment to support our Historically Black Churches as part of our ongoing effort to address issues of racism and injustice. Since 2014, the Diocese of New Jersey has provided $4,436,317 in support of our Historically Black Churches. In 2023, seven out of ten Historically Black Churches received financial support from the Diocese; for 2026, all ten of our Historically Black Churches have received financial support, in addition to an annual waiver of the Marks of Mission Giving Asking payments. In 2023, the total amount of support provided to Historically Black Churches was $437,251. For 2026, this number has risen to $522,314. This resolution does not stand alone; instead, it builds upon a well- established and growing commitment to support and care for our Historically Black Churches. 

 

The 242nd Convention called for the establishment of a Reparative Justice Financial Board to review and bring forward a proposal to fund a Reparative Justice Trust Fund for the support of the Historically Black Churches of the Diocese of New Jersey. Upon review, the Board recognizes that the work ahead is long and extensive and asks that we begin with goals for the first three years. This initial funding proposal includes an allocation from diocesan funds, a commitment to use a portion of the proceeds of the sale of diocesan-held real estate, a waiver of Marks of Mission obligations from Historically Black Churches, and a fundraising campaign as seed money to begin the work. In addition, further education for all congregations is proposed, with the expectation that the 244th convention will include a resolution seeking funding support from individual congregations to further expand the Fund. 

 

Under the resolution adopted by the 242nd Convention, the Reparative Justice Financial Board will continue to serve as the Trustees of the Reparations Fund. We note that while the Reparative Justice Financial Board provides suitable representation from the governance and leadership of the Diocese of New Jersey, it does not necessarily ensure that those communities receiving reparations will be in positions of leadership. This resolution establishes that the leadership of people of African descent will continue to shape and oversee the Fund. 

 

Please note that while diocesan-held real estate sales will contribute to the fund, sales of properties owned by or held in trust for active congregations will not be included in the assessment. The net sale proceeds of diocesan-held real estate sales include all sale transactions of properties held directly by the diocese from former congregations that are sold to non-diocesan purchasers, minus carrying costs, closing fees, legal costs, taxes (where applicable) and other costs associated with the property or its conveyance. Properties held by the diocese in partnership with other entities (for example, affordable housing development initiatives) are not considered sold and are therefore ineligible for inclusion. 

 

The Marks of Mission Giving Asking calculation is based on annual income and varies from year to year. We estimate that the value of the annual MOM payments from Historically Black Churches is approximately $140,000. This represents tangible support for our congregations of African Descent and should provide immediate reparative support. No repayment obligation will accrue for churches receiving the annual MOM waiver. 

 

Recommendation by Committee on Resolutions: 

 

The Committee recommends the adoption of this proposal. This proposal will be included in the Consent Calendar. 

 



[1] The board is a newly (2026) constituted organ of the diocese, formed under the auspices of Resolution 242-5 of the 2025 diocesan convention. It was appointed entirely by Bishop French. The membership of the board has not been published. It is neither the same body as the diocesan Anti-Racism Commission, nor the diocesan Reparations Commission. The text of Resolution 242-5 has been deleted from the Diocese of New Jersey website but may be found here: Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski, “Diocesan Convention Approves Formation of Reparative Justice Trust,” DNJRJR(November 30, 2025): https://dionj-racialjusticereview.blogspot.com/2025/11/news-diocesan-convention-approves.html.

[2] Diocese of New Jersey Committee on Resolutions, “Final Report of the Committee on Resolutions,” dioceseofnj.org (Nov. 2026): https://dioceseofnj.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/Doc-09-Resolutions-Final.pdf.

Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Diocesan Slavery History Pilgrimage Participation is Going Strong

Reparations Commission Slavery History Pilgrimage, July 18, 2026 (photo Jolyon Pruszinski)
Several groups have participated in the Diocesan Slavery History Pilgrimage in the past year, growing in their understanding of the deeply troubling history of the diocese, and committing to working for a more just future. The Reparations Commission organizes multiple opportunities each year, but it is designed so that you can also follow the pilgrimage on your own when it works best for you.

Reparations Commission Slavery History Pilgrimage, October 31, 2026 (photo Jolyon Pruszinski)

Reparations Commission Slavery History Pilgrimage, June 6, 2026 (photo Jolyon Pruszinski)

The summer pilgrimage was featured in the Province II newsletter and in the Diocese of New Jersey publication News & Notes (though the Diocese has since deleted that article). The diocese has also deleted the dedicated page on its website for the pilgrimage, but you can still access the pilgrimage materials here. The text below about the pilgrimage is preserved from Hailey Hensley's July 2026 News & Notes article.

This summer, the Diocese of New Jersey Reparations Commission welcomed    participants on two Slavery History Pilgrimages, inviting them to walk, pray, and reflect at sites connected to New Jersey's history of enslavement and the Episcopal Church's role within it.

Beginning and ending at the Perth Amboy UNESCO Slave Trade Marker, the pilgrimage followed a liturgy of prayer, reflection, and repentance as participants traveled to sites across Monmouth and Middlesex counties, including the Tinton Falls African Burial Ground, Marlpit Hall Museum, and Mount Mitchill.

For many, the experience was deeply personal. Participants found themselves standing in places they had passed countless times without recognizing the stories they held. Homes, roads, and neighborhoods that once seemed ordinary became places of remembrance, revealing the lives of enslaved people who lived and labored in the very communities many now call home.

Reflecting on the pilgrimage, Canon Annette Buchanan, Chair of the Reparations Commission, noted that its power comes from the way it connects history to the places we know today.

"While we have studied, read, and listened to the history of enslaved persons in New Jersey, the uniqueness of the pilgrimage is that we bear witness to the lives of the enslaved that are literally in our surrounding church communities, our backyards. For those of us who lived locally, we kept saying, 'I've passed this house many times. I've traveled on this street many times,' without realizing these were the same places where our enslaved ancestors lived and worked under the cruelty and pain of bondage."

Canon Buchanan also reflected on the difficult but necessary task of confronting the Church's own history.

​"We [the Church] wanted to believe we were part of the freedom movement and the Underground Railroad, but we also had to face the harsh reality of our complicity in and enrichment from the institution of slavery."

Throughout the day, participants prayed together, asking God for the courage to face that history with honesty and hope. One prayer captured the spirit of the pilgrimage: "Emmanuel, God-with-us, give us courage to awaken to and repent for our history of enslavement and systemic racism in New Jersey."

By combining prayer with learning and remembrance, the Slavery History Pilgrimages continue the Diocese of New Jersey's commitment to racial justice and reparations, reminding us that reconciliation begins by telling the truth about our shared history. 

Hailey Hensley
Diocese of New Jersey Director of Communications and Evangelism

Sunday, October 4, 2026

EVENT: Diocesan Slavery History Pilgrimage Saturday, October 31, 2026 (11am) Perth Amboy


If you missed it before, you've got another chance! The Diocese of New Jersey Reparations Commission will offer its slavery history pilgrimage again on Saturday, October 31, 2026 beginning at 11am. The pilgrimage starts and ends in Perth Amboy and follows a liturgy of reflection and repentance through a circuit of sites of memory related to Anglican and Episcopal involvement in slavery. We will meet at 11am at the Perth Amboy Ferry Slip UNESCO slave trade marker (site #1) to begin the pilgrimage. We will eat lunch between sites #2 and #3 and will plan to arrive at site #3 (Marlpit Hall) at approximately 12:50pm. Email Dr. Jolyon Pruszinski (jolyonp@princeton.edu) to let us know you'll be participating or if you have any questions. The full pilgrimage guide is available as a PDF document online or in smartphone-friendly format and you can follow it yourself at any time. For the pilgrimage participants are responsible for their own travel to/from Perth Amboy but we may be able to travel more efficiently via carpool between pilgrimage sites.

The addresses for all of the sites are included in the pilgrimage guide but are also listed here.

Site #1: Perth Amboy UNESCO slave trade marker
300 Front Street; Perth Amboy, NJ

Site #2: Tinton Falls African Burial Ground
750 Tinton Ave.; Tinton Falls, NJ 07724

Site #3: Marlpit Hall Museum
137 Kings Hwy.; Middletown, NJ 07748

Site #4: Mount Mitchill Scenic Overlook
460 Ocean Blvd.; Atlantic Highlands, NJ

Site #5: Perth Amboy UNESCO slave trade marker (same as site #1)
300 Front Street; Perth Amboy, NJ

Please be aware that it is customary to make a small donation at the Marlpit Hall Museum to support the exhibit. Also, please plan to either bring a lunch, or to buy lunch at an establishment nearby the pilgrimage route. There are many lunch options available. We are looking forward to having you join us!



Saturday, October 3, 2026

"Anglican Slavery in New Jersey" Reviewed in AEH Journal by Rev. Dr. Valerie Bailey


The first academic review of Anglican Slavery in New Jersey: An Initial Accounting (the first book produced as a result of the Diocese of New Jersey Racial Justice Review), was just published in the September issue of Anglican and Episcopal History Journal! To read the whole thing you need to become a member of the Historical Society of the Episcopal Church or you need to have access to JSTOR.ORG. But for if neither of those work for you, here are some of the highlights from the very generous review from Rev. Dr. Valerie Bailey of the Stevenson School of Ministry:

"Episcopal dioceses have been reflecting for almost twenty years about how the church may have been complicit in the slave trade and systemic racism. The Diocese of New Jersey invited a historian to the conversation. The result is a significant contribution to the history of the Episcopal Church. Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski’s recent book, Anglican Slavery in New Jersey, is a powerful example of the outcome of these conversations, especially those related to the General Convention 2006 Resolution A143 to examine and repent for complicity in slavery. Since then, dioceses have engaged in anti-racism work in the church, starting with the question of how the church was complicit in slavery. Pruszinski’s work continued a year-long reparations task force that became a commission, formed by Bishop William H. Stokes. Pruszinski has served as the historian of the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey’s Reparations Commission since 2022. His work draws from primary sources that indicate the church was not only complicit but a participant in the development of New Jersey’s slave economy (xvii). This book is a compelling example of what dioceses can do to challenge racism by going beyond “thoughts and prayers” and engaging in historical research."

"The book contains many examples of church leaders who were enslavers and whose wealth helped build the Diocese of New Jersey. “This willingness to work with and benefit from slavery at the highest levels of leadership in the diocese also translated into lay comfort with the institution,” writes Pruszinski (36). The book concludes with an invitation for more narratives related to the church’s complicity in slavery, especially the narratives of church leaders as enslavers, and the laws that disenfranchised Blacks and relegated their stories into obscurity. The conversation about racism focuses on the severe harm caused by slavery and the need for reparations – acknowledgment of the harm done, financial, or both. Pruszinski’s book introduces the tools and practices that are at the heart of being a historian, grounding this work in the betterment of the church and enriching the study of its history."

Thank you Rev. Dr. Bailey for the positive feedback on the work we are doing here in New Jersey!

Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski, Ph.D.
Reparations Commission Research Historian
Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey

Thursday, October 1, 2026

Correspondence Following the Black Caucus Response to the Steinke Report, June-July 1997


Following the wide circulation of the Black Caucus response[1] to the Steinke Report[2] on Bishop Doss’ behavior during his episcopate, which included both accusations of racism and a recommitment to acting in love toward diocesan leadership accused of racism, the Caucus reported receiving a high volume of correspondence. On July 9, 1997 the Caucus wrote publicly to “Friends” regarding this correspondence and included in their letter a facsimile of a letter they had received from the Rev. Dean Henry of Christ Church, Middletown (sent on June 25, 1997), along with the response they had sent to him on July 2, 1997. It is likely that both the letter of July 9 and that of July 2 were authored by the Rev. Cn. Dr. Leroy Lyons of St. Mark’s Episcopal Church, Plainfield, New Jersey.

            No doubt the letter from the Rev. Henry is included because it provides an example of an embarrassingly poor response from a white priest supportive of Doss, and critical of the Black Caucus. Henry’s letter is short, and ostensibly polite, but clearly alleges that the Black Caucus includes many of those “who are not truly repentant” and who “frustrate the work of the Holy Spirit.” Henry also suggests that the members of the Black Caucus need to exhibit less “willfulness.” Incredibly, though praising the exegesis exhibited in the Black Caucus response to the Steinke Report, he shows such a lack of familiarity with the letter to Philemon that he misspells Onesimus’ name several times. The glaring issues with his missive do not go unanswered. 

            Writing for the Black Caucus, Lyons similarly strikes an ostensibly polite tone, but highlights Henry’s apparent lack of familiarity with the biblical text,[3] and disputes both Henry’s argument and his allegations of sinfulness. Lyons returns to Philemon to correct Henry and to insist that neither Onesimus nor the Black Caucus acted sinfully, or “rebelliously.” Lyons insists both on the commitment to agapÄ“ that the Black Caucus maintains, and the onus of responsibility on Bishop Doss to exhibit this quality himself.

The correspondence indicates both the degree of unexamined racism that existed in white priests in the diocese at the time, the readiness with which such priests supported a racist bishop and criticized those attempting to hold him accountable, and the lengths to which the Black Caucus went to try to educate their white Episcopalian colleagues. The correspondence[4] is provided in full below, courtesy of the Rev. Cn. Dr. Leroy Lyons. 

 






Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski, Ph.D.
Reparations Commission Research Historian
Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey


[1] See “A Response to the Steinke Report From the Black Caucus, The Diocese of New Jersey,” June 14, 1997. MSS held at the private archive of the Rev. Cn. Dr. Leroy Lyons, Plainfield, New Jersey. See also Jolyon G. R. Pruszinski, “The Black Caucus Responds to the Steinke Report on Shortcomings of Doss’ Episcopal, June 14, 1997,” DNJRJR (August 2, 2026): https://dionj-racialjusticereview.blogspot.com/2026/08/the-black-caucus-responds-to-steinke.html.

[2] A report from an outside consultant who investigated allegations of problematic behavior on the part of Bishop Doss, delivered to the diocese on May 16, 1997. See David M. Herszenhorn, “An Embattled Episcopal Bishop; His Ouster Is Sought by Leaders of the New Jersey Diocese,” New York Times (December 7, 1997): Section 1, page 45. See also Pruszinski, “The Black Caucus Responds to the Steinke Report on Shortcomings of Doss’ Episcopal, June 14, 1997.”

[3] A text on which Lyons wrote his doctoral dissertation.

[4] It includes a Letter from “The members of the Black Caucus” to “Friends,” July 9, `1997, which

appends the following letters: Letter from The Rev. Dean Henry to The Black Caucus, June 25, 1997; and Letter from “Members of the Black Caucus” to The Rev. Dean Henry, July 2, 1997. MSS held at the private archive of the Rev. Cn. Dr. Leroy Lyons, Plainfield, New Jersey.

Wednesday, September 9, 2026

EVENT: "Lamentation" An Exhibit of Paintings by Jane Otto, with an Artist Talk on Reparations, September 23, 2026

Calligrapher Jane Otto will be showing her artwork, "Lamentation," at Christ Church, New Brunswick, Wednesday evening, September 23, 2026 at 6:30 p.m. Inspired by illuminated manuscripts, Lamentation suggests a path to healing through reparations. The accompanying talk about reparations will complement the art with a concrete framework and road map for reparative justice. Please join us for an engaging evening of art and discussion, with reception to follow. Sponsored by the Reparations Commission of the Episcopal Diocese of New Jersey. Address is 5 Paterson Street, New Brunswick, NJ.